Submitted by Nick K / University of Michigan-Flint on Thu, 03/03/2011 - 09:29
Forums
Wow how exciting my very first post!I am in the first year of my tenure-track appointment and i am currently teaching a jr/sr inorganic class for the first time. The person that i am replacing left under very unfriendly terms and as a consequence the lab component of the course hasn't been offered in 3 or 4 years. Starting in the winter 2012 I will be teaching the lab again and have been told by the chair that they want it rebuilt from the ground up and to take a no restrictions approach to designing it.I am looking for any suggestions from the VIPEr community as to what should be included in this type of lab or things that you have found that work really well or is good for teaching a particular topic. I have a glovebox in my research lab that was donated by my Ph.D. Institution along with a schlenk line that is dedicated to the lab itself. We are however limited in instrumentation. We have the basics as far as IR, GC, HPLC, Fluorescence, but we only have a 90 MHz NMR and any sort of solid state analysis is pretty much out of the question. Any advice would be greatly appreciated!Nick
Anne Bentley / Lewis & Clark College
Is your lab course separated from the lecture course?  If so, your format is similar to ours.  Our inorganic lab (which is taken either before or after the lecture portion of the course) has a once-a-week lecture and a once-a-week 4-hour lab.  I will be returning to teaching it this fall after a two-year hiatus, so I’m also interested in what others have to say.

 

In the past, we have adapted labs from Girolami, Rauchfuss, and Angelici’s “Synthesis and Technique in Inorganic Chemistry” book – specifically, we have done the YBa2Cu3Ox superconductor lab (and we didn’t have a diffractometer), the Mo-Mo quadruple bonds lab (#11), and the nickelocene lab (#20, though we start with commercially available nickelocene).  I like the nickelocene lab because it gives them glove box and Schlenk line experience.  I’ve also adapted a porphyrin lab I found in the Chemical Educator (2005, vol 10, p. 120-125).  Everyone synthesizes the porphyrin ligand, but then each student makes their own complex with a different transition metal ion.   Finally, a good lab to introduce nanoscience (as well as to emphasize absorption vs fluorescence spectroscopy) can be found in J Chem Ed – 2005, vol 82, p. 1697.

 

I hope this helps get you started.  

Wed, 03/09/2011 - 13:59 Permalink
Adam Johnson / Harvey Mudd College

My course is also a separate course; one 4-hour laboratory session per week.Many (not all, maybe half) of my experiments are from (loosely or tightly) these two references:

Szafran, Z; Pike, R. M.; Singh, M. M.  Microscale Inorganic Chemistry

Girolami, G. S.; Rauchfuss, T. B.; Angelici, R. J.  Synthesis and Technique in Inorganic Chemistry,3rd Ed.

 with a smattering of input from

Woolins, J. D.  Inorganic Experiments

The rest are cobbled together from stuff I made up over the years, pre-existing labs, and stuff from the literature.

here is what we make {and the major take homes}

a series of MnBr(CO)2(dppm)(PR3) complexes, {IR/31P NMR}

Co(salen) {IR and O2 absorptio}

Pd-coupling (Buchwald/Hartwig) of an aryl bromide and an amine {organometallics and catalysis}

YBCO superconductor {non-stoichiometric compounds}

Co(en)3 {chirality, UV-Vis}

phosphazene {31P NMR, IR, main group compounds}

 M(acac) complexes {paramagnetic NMR, Evans method, UV-Vis}

(arene)Cr(CO)3 {IR,13C NMR}

Ru=C complexes {13C NMR, catalytic ring closing metathesis}

 

Not all students make all the compounds; its "choose your own adventure."  I am happy to share most of my materials, just ask.  Some of it is here on ViPEr (the manganese carbonyl experiment and the Pd coupling, for example).

Wed, 03/09/2011 - 23:20 Permalink
Ed Donnay / McMurry University

I am teaching inorganic this fall and decided to try the project laid out in this J. Chem. Educ. article (2003, 80 (3), p 307) where the author describes adapting published research into lab experiments.  I am having trouble synthesizing the MnIII(salpn)(acac) complex which is the first part of week 2.  The "detailed" synthesis laid out in the supplementary information to the J. Chem. Educ. paper is significantly different than that described in the research article with no explanation why.  I am just wondering if anyone currently uses this project or has in the past where the synthesis worked.

Wed, 09/05/2012 - 20:57 Permalink
Chris Mullins / University of Kentucky

Edward,

Since I worked on Mn chemistry (and used the H2Salpn ligand even) I am trying to track down a copy of the Larsen paper from 1991.

My best guess is that you may be making Mn(III)(salpn)(CH3OH)+ which is readily being oxidized to the mu-oxo dimer, complex 3 in Michael Baldwin's JCE paper...what exactly is the color of your product(s)? If you have some of the green (complex 1) it might be possible to isolate pure compounds using chromatography.

I'm getting kinda rusty on the Mn chemistry as its now been over 4.5 years since I worked on any of it...but I hope maybe this helps.

Let me know how it works out, because I agree this is a great set of labs that I'd love to use if and when we ever have a semester-long inorganic lab course.

Best wishes!

:) Chris

Thu, 09/13/2012 - 16:07 Permalink
Ed Donnay / McMurry University

Chris,

Thanks for the response.  The student-made sample was a dark tar that did dry to a mixture of green and black solid after washing with ether, so it might be complex #1.  It just took a long time to isolate and was not pure.  I tried the synthesis myself and let it reflux longer, but I got  black crystals which seemed identical to Mn(acac)3 or recovered starting material.  I just thought that if this has been used in lab classes before (i.e. 3-4 hour periods), the synthesis should be relatively hassle free so that students have time to make complex #2 from #1 in the same period as suggested.  Therefore I must be missing some pertinent information.  If I find out any more, I will post it here.

Ed

Mon, 09/17/2012 - 11:49 Permalink